VOTE PENDING
We are tracking every vote. Here is who is on the record, and who needs to hear from you before the vote.
Strays need a shelter. Monday, the Council votes.
Confirmed on the City agenda: Monday, November 23, 2026, 5:30 pm, Council Chambers, 316 N. 26th Street, 5th floor, Billings. Read the agenda packet. Written testimony due 3 pm that day (reported, not confirmed). Verify with the City Clerk, Denise Bohlman, 406.657.8210.
Our ask Our opinion
Do not let lost and stray animals fall into a gap.
Item 3 is on the Nov 23 agenda as of Nov 21. YVAS says it cannot afford to subsidize a transition at its own expense (YVAS statement, Nov 20, Source 40). Read the agenda packet.
Tell the Council: approve a workable agreement that keeps an established shelter partner taking Billings strays. Explain publicly how strays and lost pets, including cats, will be handled starting the day after the vote. Run a transparent process for any new provider.
Who has done what
Three separate things are happening. We name who is acting in each.
City selection committee Reported
told RFP respondents on Nov 4 that it chose another proposer to negotiate with. No provider was named. There was no Council vote. This is a staff and committee decision. Source 39.
YVAS Party statement, reported
says it stopped taking city stray intake on Nov 5 and, on Nov 20, that it cannot afford to subsidize the month-to-month transition at its own expense. Source 35, Source 40.
The City Council Verified agenda
has one related item on its Nov 23 agenda as of Nov 21: Item 3, the YVAS month-to-month agreement. Check the final agenda. Source 23.
Where each member stands: the Nov 23 vote
Our keep and vote-out recommendations come after the vote, based on how each member votes. We will publish them here with the record.
NOT YET VOTED ON ITEM 3 (11)
Mike Nelson
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Presides over the Council. Voted yes with the majority to dissolve the Animal Control Advisory Board (9-2, Jul 27, 2026).
Kendra Shaw
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Voted yes on the Nov 24, 2025 short-term YVAS agreement (11-0). Attended the Oct 12, 2026 meeting by Zoom.
Mark Nicholson
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Seconded the Nov 2 direction to put the YVAS agreement on the Nov 23 agenda. Voted no to dissolve the Animal Control Advisory Board.
Roy Neese
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Voted yes on the Nov 24, 2025 short-term YVAS agreement (11-0). Moved the Nov 2 direction to continue the RFP process.
Denis Pitman
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Seconded two of the four Nov 2 work session directions (limit services; continue the RFP process).
Bill Kennedy
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Voted yes on the Nov 24, 2025 short-term YVAS agreement (11-0). Seconded the motion to dissolve the Animal Control Advisory Board.
Amy Aguirre
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Voted no on repealing the Animal Control Advisory Board (Sep 28 and Oct 12, 2026).
Scott Aspenlieder
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Voted yes on the Nov 24, 2025 short-term YVAS agreement (11-0). Abstained on the Wilson Park annexation (Mar 24, 2025) after disclosing that his employer was involved in the project.
Andrew Lindley
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Moved the Nov 2 direction to put the YVAS agreement on the Nov 23 agenda. Told KTVQ he is disappointed the City and YVAS could not find middle ground.
Mike Boyett
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Seconded the Nov 24, 2025 short-term YVAS agreement (11-0). Moved two of the four Nov 2 work session directions.
Tony O'Donnell
Item 3: Not yet voted
On the record: Present for all four Nov 2 work session directions (unanimous). Voted yes to dissolve the Animal Control Advisory Board.
Verdicts, when we publish them, are our opinion based on the cited public record. See the full record and our sources.
Ward 1: your two councilmembers and the mayor
- Kendra Shaw Ward 1 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Mark Nicholson Ward 1 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Mike Nelson Mayor (votes for the whole city) Item 3: Not yet voted
Ward 2: your two councilmembers and the mayor
- Roy Neese Ward 2 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Denis Pitman Ward 2 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Mike Nelson Mayor (votes for the whole city) Item 3: Not yet voted
Ward 3: your two councilmembers and the mayor
- Bill Kennedy Ward 3 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Amy Aguirre Ward 3 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Mike Nelson Mayor (votes for the whole city) Item 3: Not yet voted
Ward 4: your two councilmembers and the mayor
- Scott Aspenlieder Ward 4 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Andrew Lindley Ward 4 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Mike Nelson Mayor (votes for the whole city) Item 3: Not yet voted
Ward 5: your two councilmembers and the mayor
- Mike Boyett Ward 5 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Tony O'Donnell Ward 5 councilmember Item 3: Not yet voted
- Mike Nelson Mayor (votes for the whole city) Item 3: Not yet voted
What to do in 60 seconds
Email
Email your ward's two members and the Mayor. Ask them to keep an established shelter partner taking Billings strays, explain how strays and lost pets will be handled after the vote, and run a transparent process for any new provider. The Email buttons above write it for you. Add your name and ward.
Call
Use the Call buttons above. Say: “My name is ___. I live in Ward ___. I am calling about stray animal sheltering and Agenda Item 3 on Monday. Please keep an established shelter partner taking Billings strays, and explain how lost pets, including cats, will be handled starting the day after the vote. Thank you.” You can also leave a message with City Hall at 406.657.8433.
Show up or send written testimony
The Council meets Monday, Nov 23, 5:30 pm, Council Chambers, 316 N. 26th Street, 5th floor. To speak, sign in on the speaker roster at the back of the room. You get 3 minutes, or the time the Mayor sets (City minutes).
To send written comments, email council@billingsmt.gov, the City's all-council address. Written testimony is reported due by 3 pm that day. That cutoff is not confirmed. Ask the City Clerk: City Clerk Denise Bohlman, 406.657.8210, bohlmand@billingsmt.gov .
Share
Send this page to one neighbor: billingspetvotes.org
Register and vote
Check that you are registered, or find your polling place, at the state voter lookup. The Yellowstone County elections office handles registration.
You vote only for the councilmembers in your own ward, plus the Mayor. Five ward seats have terms ending Dec 31, 2027 (Shaw, Neese, Kennedy, Aspenlieder, Boyett), and Mayor Nelson's term runs through 2029, per the City's pages. Shaw, Neese and Boyett are in second terms and are term-limited per the city charter (confirm with the City Clerk). The next city election is reported for Tuesday, Nov 2, 2027. Verify the date with the County.
What happened
Facts only, each linked to a source. Items marked Reported come from news or from a party to the dispute.
2008 Reported by YVAS
The City first contracted with YVAS for stray animal care. Source 22
September 10, 2025 Verified
Smoke exposure during narcotics incineration at the city-owned animal facility. Per the City's Sep 15 update, 14 shelter employees and 5 law enforcement officers were treated at a hospital and no animals were lost. Source 34
November 24, 2025 Verified (draft minutes)
Council approved a short-term agreement with YVAS through June 30, 2026, 11-0. Source 31
June 30, 2026 Verified
The YVAS agreement expired. Source 27
July 1, 2026 Verified
The City took over shelter operations. Source 27
July and September 2026 Verified
A second RFP was issued July 9 and drew two proposals (YVAS and K9 Hope Broker). On Sep 21 the Council reached consensus to form a committee to return with options. Source 25
November 2, 2026 Verified
At a work session the Council passed four directions to staff by voice vote, all unanimous. One placed a YVAS month-to-month agreement on the Nov 23 agenda for consideration. It did not approve the agreement. Source 24
November 4, 2026 Reported
City Purchasing told RFP respondents that the selection committee chose another proposer to negotiate with (a committee decision, not a Council vote). The email names no provider. Source 39
November 5, 2026 Reported
YVAS says it stopped accepting stray and lost animals from inside Billings city limits. Source 35
November 20, 2026 YVAS statement (party to the dispute)
YVAS says it learned the City intends to move forward with another provider, and that it cannot afford to subsidize a month-to-month transition at its own expense. YVAS says the Council was scheduled to consider that agreement on Nov 23. Source 40
November 23, 2026 Verified agenda, vote pending
The Council's agenda, revised 11/19 and checked Nov 21, lists Item 3, the temporary month-to-month agreement with YVAS at $33,042.63 per month. The agenda says approval would not decide the RFP process. Vote pending. Check the final agenda. Source 23
Rumor vs. record
What people are saying, and what the record shows. Each row links to its source.
Claim “Council voted to replace YVAS.”
Record No Council vote on a replacement exists.
Claim “Council voted against YVAS.”
Record No current member has voted against a YVAS agreement. Every recorded YVAS vote in our record was unanimous. The only recorded no votes were on the Animal Control Advisory Board, not on YVAS.
Claim “The City picked a new provider.”
Record The City's selection committee told RFP respondents on Nov 4 that it chose another proposer to negotiate with. No provider was named. A contract would return to the Council for approval.
Claim “Council will vote on a new provider on Nov 23.”
Record The agenda lists the YVAS agreement, not a new provider. Check the final agenda.
Verified Source 23
Claim “Billings Animal Control will take my stray.”
Record Reporting says Billings Animal Control is taking only vicious animals and legal holds. At the Nov 2 work session the Council directed staff to limit City-funded services to dogs at large, dangerous, injured, court-hold, and lost or abandoned dogs. That was direction to staff, not a formal vote.
Claim “YVAS provided four months of unpaid service.”
Record That is YVAS's claim. The City's account differs on who declined what.
Claim “YVAS is closing.”
Record YVAS says no. It says stray intake from city limits ended Nov 5 and its other services continue.
Who runs this site
billingspetvotes.org is an independent effort by a resident of the Billings area. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or coordinated with Yellowstone Valley Animal Shelter, any other shelter or rescue, the City of Billings, any political party, or any candidate. Nobody here speaks for the shelter. When we quote or cite the shelter, it is from its own public statements.
This site takes a side on the record and says so. Every vote links to a public source. Recommendations are opinion, labeled as ours. See how we decide.